Call for Papers:Vol.12 Issue.2

Submission
Last date		 28-Apr-2026
Acceptance Status In One Day
Paper Publish In Two Days
Submit ManuScript

News & Updates

Submit Article

Dear Authors, Article publish in our journal for Volume-12,Issue-2. For article submission on below link: Submit Manuscript


Join As Board

Dear Reviewer, You can join our Reviewer team without given any charges in our journal. Submit Details on below link: Join As Board


Paper Publication Charges

IJARIIE APP
Download Android App

For Authors

Archives

IJARIIE Board

Downloads

Android App

Download IJARIIE APP

Authors

Title: :  Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach
PaperId: :  28340
Published in:   International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education
Publisher:   IJARIIE
e-ISSN:   2395-4396
Volume/Issue:    Volume 12 Issue 2 2026
DUI:    16.0415/IJARIIE-28340
Licence: :   IJARIIE is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Author NameAuthor Institute
Fe U. Abrahan ANDRES SORIANO COLLEGES OF BISLIG
Rio S. Consigna,Phd ANDRES SORIANO COLLEGES OF BISLIG

Abstract

EDUCATIONAL MANAGEMENT
Unified Monitoring Tool; Reliability; Validity; Cohen’s Kappa; Content Validity Index; Educational Monitoring; Data-Driven Governance
This study examined the reliability and validity of the Schools Governance and Operations Division (SGOD) Unified Monitoring Tool (UMT) utilized in the Department of Education (DepEd) Bislig City Division. Grounded in the increasing demand for data-driven governance and accountability in education, the research aimed to assess whether the UMT provides consistent and accurate measurements in evaluating school programs, activities, and projects (PAPs). A descriptive-evaluative research design was employed, involving 15 randomly selected elementary and secondary schools from a total population of 70 schools within the division. Inter-rater reliability was determined using Cohen’s Kappa coefficient, while content validity was assessed through the Content Validity Index (CVI) based on expert evaluations. Findings revealed that the UMT demonstrated low inter-rater reliability, with a mean Kappa value of 0.25, indicating weak agreement among evaluators. In contrast, the tool exhibited excellent content validity, achieving a perfect CVI score of 1.00, signifying that all indicators were considered highly relevant, clear, and representative of the intended constructs. The disparity between reliability and validity suggests that inconsistencies are primarily attributable to variations in tool implementation rather than deficiencies in its conceptual design. Key factors influencing reliability include differences in monitor competency, ambiguity in certain qualitative indicators, lack of standardized training and calibration, and variability in school compliance during monitoring periods. The study concludes that while the UMT is a valid instrument for assessing school governance and operations, its reliability requires improvement. It recommends the implementation of structured capacity-building programs, refinement of indicator definitions, and the establishment of standardized monitoring protocols to enhance consistency. These findings contribute to strengthening monitoring and evaluation systems and support evidence-based decision-making in educational management.

Citations

Copy and paste a formatted citation or use one of the links to import into a bibliography manager and reference.

IJARIIE Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd . "Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach" International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education Volume 12 Issue 2 2026 Page 1679-1683
MLA Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd . "Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach." International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education 12.2(2026) : 1679-1683.
APA Fe U. Abrahan , & Rio S. Consigna,Phd . (2026). Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach. International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, 12(2), 1679-1683.
Chicago Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd . "Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach." International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education 12, no. 2 (2026) : 1679-1683.
Oxford Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd . 'Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach', International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 12, no. 2, 2026, p. 1679-1683. Available from IJARIIE, http://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/Reliability_and_validity_of_Schools_Governance_and_Operations_Division_Unified_Monitoring_Tool_of_Bislig_City_Division__A_Descriptive__Evaluative_Approach_ijariie28340.pdf (Accessed : ).
Harvard Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd . (2026) 'Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach', International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, 12(2), pp. 1679-1683IJARIIE [Online]. Available at: http://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/Reliability_and_validity_of_Schools_Governance_and_Operations_Division_Unified_Monitoring_Tool_of_Bislig_City_Division__A_Descriptive__Evaluative_Approach_ijariie28340.pdf (Accessed : )
IEEE Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd , "Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach," International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 1679-1683, Mar-App 2026. [Online]. Available: http://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/Reliability_and_validity_of_Schools_Governance_and_Operations_Division_Unified_Monitoring_Tool_of_Bislig_City_Division__A_Descriptive__Evaluative_Approach_ijariie28340.pdf [Accessed : ].
Turabian Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd . "Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach." International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education [Online]. volume 12 number 2 ().
Vancouver Fe U. Abrahan , and Rio S. Consigna,Phd . Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative Approach. International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education [Internet]. 2026 [Cited : ]; 12(2) : 1679-1683. Available from: http://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/Reliability_and_validity_of_Schools_Governance_and_Operations_Division_Unified_Monitoring_Tool_of_Bislig_City_Division__A_Descriptive__Evaluative_Approach_ijariie28340.pdf
BibTex EndNote RefMan RefWorks

Number Of Downloads



Save in Google Drive

Similar-Paper

TitleArea of ResearchAuther NameAction
Factors Influencing the Adoption of Bio-Plastics among ConsumersManagementAnkita Download
Reliability and validity of Schools Governance and Operations Division Unified Monitoring Tool of Bislig City Division: A Descriptive Evaluative ApproachEDUCATIONAL MANAGEMENTFe U. Abrahan Download
Implementation of the Scheduled Caste Sub-Plan in Rajasthan: Policy Framework, Budgetary Allocations and Development OutcomesManagementDr. Mahendra Singh Rao Download
GENDER INFLUENCES ON NEGOTIATION TACTICS IN WORKPLACE CONFLICTSAccounting & FinanceLeqele Manngope Maureen Download
A POLICY BRIEF IN THE MAKING THE CHALLENGES AND MENTORSHIP QUALITY OF STUDENT TEACHERS IN CONTRASTING SCHOOL ENVIRONMENTSEducational ManagementEVA QUIRANTE EBORDE Download
Perceived Social Learning-Related Factors and Academic Outcomes of Grade 9 Learners in Edukasyon sa Pagpapakatao in Democrito O. Plaza Memorial National High School, Agusan del Sur Division: A Descriptive-Correlational ApproachEducationEden G. Sapio Download
Influence Of Leadership Style on Conflict Management in Private Secondary Schools In Kayunga District, UgandaManagement Enoch Tumusiime Download
A STUDY ON FACTORS INFLUENCING DISCHARGE DELAY IN PATIENT CARE AT ONE OF THE MULTISPECIALITY HOSPITALS IN COIMBATOREHOSPITAL ADMINISTRATIONMrs. U. SUJI Download
A DESCRIPTIVE SURVEY ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF TECHNICAL VOCATIONAL LIVELIHOOD (TVL) TRACKS AND THE CHALLENGES ENCOUNTERED BY TVL LEARNERS OF SALVACION NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL: BASIS FOR IMPROVED INSTRUCTIONEducationJowel S. Piquit Download
Role of CSR and Benefits on Employee Performance Across Generations and GendersManagement Md Naim-Ul-Hasan Khan Download
Prison Reforms in Haryana: Issues and InitiativesMANAGEMENTSachin Kumar Download
Disaster Risk Reduction Strategies and Community Preparedness of Coastal Communities in Glan, Sarangani ProvinceManagementKamarudin A. Sagandi Download
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SOCIAL LEARNING-RELATED VARIABLES AND ACADEMIC OUTCOMES OF GRADE 9 ARALING PANLIPUNAN LEARNERS OF SALVACION NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL, AGUSAN DEL SUR DIVISION: A DESCRIPTIVE-CORRELATIONAL APPROACHEducationEVA L. VERTUDAZO Download
Transformations in Financial Networks Among Women Entrepreneurs Post-Demonetization: A Comparative Analysis by Family Structure and Digital IntegrationManagementProf. S. S. Sarangdevot Download
Laboratory Informatics as National Infrastructure: Empirical Evidence on Laboratory Information Management Systems and Geographic Information Systems Integration and Pandemic Response Performance in the United StatesManagementNiranjana Raghunathan Download
12