Call for Papers:Vol.12 Issue.1

Submission
Last date		 28-Feb-2026
Acceptance Status In One Day
Paper Publish In Two Days
Submit ManuScript

News & Updates

Submit Article

Dear Authors, Article publish in our journal for Volume-12,Issue-1. For article submission on below link: Submit Manuscript


Join As Board

Dear Reviewer, You can join our Reviewer team without given any charges in our journal. Submit Details on below link: Join As Board


Paper Publication Charges

IJARIIE APP
Download Android App

For Authors

Archives

IJARIIE Board

Downloads

Android App

Download IJARIIE APP

Authors

Title: :  The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors
PaperId: :  27581
Published in:   International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education
Publisher:   IJARIIE
e-ISSN:   2395-4396
Volume/Issue:    Volume 11 Issue 5 2025
DUI:    16.0415/IJARIIE-27581
Licence: :   IJARIIE is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Author NameAuthor Institute
Mr. Manish Pratap SinghShri Ramswaroop Memorial University
Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. ShabranShri Ramswaroop Memorial University

Abstract

Corporate Laws
Independent Directors, Corporate Governance, Boardroom Dynamics, Objectivity, SEBI Regulations.
The institution of independent directors has emerged as a cornerstone of modern corporate governance, designed to safeguard accountability, transparency, and the interests of minority shareholders. In theory, independent directors act as neutral custodians who monitor managerial behaviour and balance the competing claims of promoters, managers and stakeholders. However, in practice, their capacity to exercise true independence is frequently constrained, creating a paradox where independence exists in form but not in substance. This paper critically examines the challenges faced by independent directors in maintaining objectivity, particularly within the Indian corporate landscape, while drawing upon global experiences. Building on theoretical foundations such as Agency Theory and Stewardship Theory, the article explores how structural limitations, including boardroom dynamics, information asymmetry and entrenched promoter dominance, undermine directors’ impartiality. Additional obstacles such as tenure and remuneration structures, professional and social networks and risks of marginalization further dilute their independence. The study integrates case illustrations from India, such as the Satyam scandal and the Tata-Cyrus Mistry dispute, as well as global examples like Enron and Lehman Brothers, to highlight how statutory independence can fail without substantive empowerment. The article also evaluates regulatory frameworks, including the Companies Act, 2013 and SEBI’s Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements (LODR) Regulations, 2015, alongside international instruments such as the OECD Principles of Corporate Governance and the Sarbanes Oxley Act. While these frameworks have institutionalized independence, their effectiveness remains questionable when informal pressures, promoter influence and weak enforcement prevail. To address these challenges, the article advocates for stronger information rights, enhanced board diversity, continuous training and capacity building, institutional support from regulators and investors, and above all, a cultural transformation within boardrooms. The conclusion emphasizes that bridging the gap between statutory independence and substantive independence requires not merely compliance but the cultivation of a governance culture that values transparency, dissent and accountability.

Citations

Copy and paste a formatted citation or use one of the links to import into a bibliography manager and reference.

IJARIIE Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. "The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors" International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education Volume 11 Issue 5 2025 Page 868-878
MLA Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. "The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors." International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education 11.5(2025) : 868-878.
APA Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, & Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. (2025). The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors. International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, 11(5), 868-878.
Chicago Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. "The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors." International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education 11, no. 5 (2025) : 868-878.
Oxford Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. 'The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors', International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 11, no. 5, 2025, p. 868-878. Available from IJARIIE, https://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/The_Paradox_of_Independence__Challenges_in_Maintaining_Objectivity_of_Independent_Directors_ijariie27581.pdf (Accessed : ).
Harvard Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. (2025) 'The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors', International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, 11(5), pp. 868-878IJARIIE [Online]. Available at: https://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/The_Paradox_of_Independence__Challenges_in_Maintaining_Objectivity_of_Independent_Directors_ijariie27581.pdf (Accessed : )
IEEE Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran, "The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors," International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 11, no. 5, pp. 868-878, Sep-Oct 2025. [Online]. Available: https://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/The_Paradox_of_Independence__Challenges_in_Maintaining_Objectivity_of_Independent_Directors_ijariie27581.pdf [Accessed : ].
Turabian Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. "The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors." International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education [Online]. volume 11 number 5 ().
Vancouver Mr. Manish Pratap Singh, and Prof. (Dr.) Rohit P. Shabran. The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent Directors. International Journal Of Advance Research And Innovative Ideas In Education [Internet]. 2025 [Cited : ]; 11(5) : 868-878. Available from: https://ijariie.com/AdminUploadPdf/The_Paradox_of_Independence__Challenges_in_Maintaining_Objectivity_of_Independent_Directors_ijariie27581.pdf
BibTex EndNote RefMan RefWorks

Number Of Downloads



Save in Google Drive

Similar-Paper

TitleArea of ResearchAuther NameAction
CYBER LAWS IN INDIA: A STUDY OF LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND SOCIAL IMPLICATIONSLawDeepika Sharma Download
A SOCIO - LEGAL STUDY ON CYBER LAWS IN INDIA WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO REGULATIONS OF CYBER SPACE AND ITS IMPLICATIONSLawDeepika Sharma Download
Law Enforcement Agencies Within the Legal Paradigm of Human Trafficking: An Analytical Study of India’s Anti-Trafficking FrameworkLawAkanksha Tiwari Download
Assessing the Efficacy of India's National Green Tribunal: An Analysis of Implementation Challenges and Access to Environmental JusticeLawTharun R Download
Independent Directors and Corporate Scandals in India: Lessons from IL&FS, ICICI and SatyamCorporate LawMr. Manish Pratap Singh Download
Living Knowledge, Living Law: Safeguarding Traditional Knowledge and Customary Practices within Plural Legal FrameworksLawDravyesh Narayan Pathak Download
“Restorative Justice Principles for Juveniles: A pathway to Juvenile Social Reintegration”LawFlori Dwivedi Download
Transforming lives of Women within a Plural Marriage: An attempt to Restrict Polygamy In India and critical analysis of gender-neutral lawsConstitutional Law and Gender JusticeSadaf Tariq Download
The Paradox of Independence: Challenges in Maintaining Objectivity of Independent DirectorsCorporate LawsMr. Manish Pratap Singh Download
Commercial Arbitration Landscape in India: A Critical AppraisalLaw Amita Agarwal Download
Privacy Rights in the Digital Era: A Critical AnalysisLawProf. (Dr.) Upendra Nath Tiwari Download
Constitutional Safeguards for Clean Air under the Indian ConstitutionEnvironmental LawMeghna Singh Download
Distribution of Profits and Allocation of Losses under OHADA Law: Towards a more balanced Governance?Private LawTATSEMDJO Romeo Download
A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE LAW OF SPIES AND ITS CONTEMPORARY ISSUESEspionage LawKhushi Dwivedi Download
Loan Insurance Contract Policy As A Legal Means To Protect Debtors Of Financial Institution In CameroonLawDr. Tita Buma Valentine Download
12