AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking
Abstract & Details
Research Area
Artificial Intelligence (AI), Natural Language Processing (NLP), Machine Learning (ML), and Educational Technology.
Keywords
Keywords: AI debate mentor
argument analysis
educational feedback
natural language processing
Random Forest
argument quality
Abstract
Debate practice involves more than choosing a side. A student needs to state a position, explain it, support it, and respond to another person's ideas. This paper reviews five conference publications from 2024 and 2025 and examines how their ideas relate to the AI Debate Mentor project. The selected studies cover debate judging, argument quality, context-aware scoring, debate generation, and feedback for argumentative writing. The project combines a Flask website, SQLite storage, rule-based language analysis, an Argument Structure Analyzer, and a Random Forest skill classifier. It also provides an optional language-model connection and a local template-based debate partner. The review finds that the project offers a useful foundation for guided practice, but its scores are indicators rather than validated educational assessments. Its synthetic training data cannot establish real student skill, and its local fallback does not generate genuinely new reasoning. Better labeled data, human review, and a student evaluation are needed before claiming learning benefits. This paper presents those limitations and a practical path for further development. Particular attention is given to the difference between detecting an argument component and judging its quality. A response may contain all four components while still using weak evidence. The review therefore treats the checklist as a guide for revision and identifies human assessment as the next step toward dependable feedback. Its contribution is a practical comparison of published approaches with the implemented application, showing which capabilities exist, where the assessment remains limited, and how future validation can be planned with real student responses and independent teacher judgments.
License
This work is licensed under a Creative
Commons
Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Author Information
| # | Name | Institute / Affiliation |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Khushi Gedam | Guru Nanak Institute of Technology Nagpur |
| 2 | Bhageshri Sonule | Guru Nanak Institute of Technology Nagpur |
| 3 | Komal Kude | Guru Nanak Institute of Technology Nagpur |
| 4 | Prof. Komal Gaikwad | Guru Nanak Institute of Technology Nagpur |
| 5 | Prof. Jagruti Ghatole | Guru Nanak Institute of Technology Nagpur |
| 6 | Dr. Bharti Sayankar | Guru Nanak Institute of Technology Nagpur |
| 7 | Dr. Sudhir N. Shelke | Guru Nanak Institute of Technology Nagpur |
How to Cite
Use the following formats to cite this article in your research.
APA Style
Gedam, Khushi, Sonule, Bhageshri, Kude, Komal, Gaikwad, Prof. Komal, Ghatole, Prof. Jagruti, Sayankar, Dr. Bharti, & Shelke, Dr. Sudhir N. (2026). AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking. International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, 12(5), 513-520.
MLA Style
Gedam, Khushi, et al. "AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking." International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 12, no. 5, 2026, pp. 513-520.
IEEE Style
Khushi Gedam, Bhageshri Sonule, Komal Kude, Prof. Komal Gaikwad, Prof. Jagruti Ghatole, Dr. Bharti Sayankar, and Dr. Sudhir N. Shelke, "AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking," International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 12, no. 5, pp. 513-520, 2026.
Vancouver Style
Gedam Khushi, Sonule Bhageshri, Kude Komal, Gaikwad Prof. Komal, Ghatole Prof. Jagruti, Sayankar Dr. Bharti, et al. AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking. International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education. 2026;12(5):513-520.
Harvard Style
Gedam, Khushi, Sonule, Bhageshri, Kude, Komal, Gaikwad, Prof. Komal, Ghatole, Prof. Jagruti, Sayankar, Dr. Bharti, & Shelke, Dr. Sudhir N. (2026) 'AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking', International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, 12(5), pp. 513-520.
Chicago Style
Gedam, Khushi, et al. "AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking." International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education 12, no. 5 (2026): 513-520.
Turabian Style
Gedam, Khushi, et al. "AI Debate Mentor for Communication and Critical Thinking." International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education 12, no. 5 (2026): 513-520.
Related Research
EduQuest AI: A Gamified Learning Platform for Interactive and Personalized Digital Education
Download PDF
Distributed Real-Time Stream Analytics and Ingestion Engine for High-Velocity Big Data Architectures
Download PDF