The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG
Abstract & Details
Research Area
Commerce and Business Management
Keywords
corporate social responsibility
stakeholder theory
shareholder primacy
shared value
triple bottom line
ESG
Abstract
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) theory has moved through four overlapping phases: a moral phase (Bowen, 1953), a performance and stakeholder phase (Carroll, 1979; Freeman, 1984), an instrumental "business case" phase (McWilliams & Siegel, 2001; Porter & Kramer, 2006), and a financialised, regulated environmental, social and governance (ESG) phase. This paper traces that development and sets out the strongest arguments for and against each phase, drawing on landmark theoretical and empirical studies. The evidence points to a modestly positive but heterogeneous link between social and financial performance, weak measurement standards, and persistent concern about greenwashing and managerial self-interest. The paper concludes that the most defensible position is conditional: responsibility creates value and legitimacy where issues are material, credibly measured and properly governed, and it should not be sold as a universal route to higher profit. The study adopts a chronological and thematic literature-review approach and compares the normative foundations, managerial frameworks, strategic rationales, institutional influences and investor-oriented interpretations that have shaped contemporary corporate responsibility. It distinguishes the question of what firms owe stakeholders from the narrower financial question of whether responsible behaviour improves investment outcomes. Particular attention is given to shareholder agency and accountability, stakeholder salience, the limitations of triple-bottom-line measurement, divergence in ESG ratings, the materiality of sustainability issues and the gap between corporate disclosure and actual performance. By juxtaposing foundational arguments with meta-analyses and selected empirical studies, the review identifies why apparently favourable findings cannot be interpreted as uniform or necessarily causal. It also highlights the implications of national institutions and changing disclosure regimes for future research. The central implication is that credible social responsibility requires issue-specific evaluation, transparent measurement and governance arrangements that make managerial commitments accountable to affected parties
License
This work is licensed under a Creative
Commons
Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Author Information
| # | Name | Institute / Affiliation |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | RAHUL MAHADEO MHABDE | Hinduja College of Commerce and Economics |
| 2 | Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh Vilekar | Hinduja College of Commerce and Economics |
How to Cite
Use the following formats to cite this article in your research.
APA Style
MHABDE, RAHUL MAHADEO & Vilekar, Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh (2026). The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG. International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, 12(5), 704-712.
MLA Style
MHABDE, RAHUL MAHADEO, and Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh Vilekar. "The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG." International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 12, no. 5, 2026, pp. 704-712.
IEEE Style
RAHUL MAHADEO MHABDE and Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh Vilekar, "The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG," International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, vol. 12, no. 5, pp. 704-712, 2026.
Vancouver Style
MHABDE RAHUL MAHADEO, Vilekar Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh. The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG. International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education. 2026;12(5):704-712.
Harvard Style
MHABDE, RAHUL MAHADEO & Vilekar, Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh (2026) 'The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG', International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education, 12(5), pp. 704-712.
Chicago Style
MHABDE, RAHUL MAHADEO and Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh Vilekar. "The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG." International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education 12, no. 5 (2026): 704-712.
Turabian Style
MHABDE, RAHUL MAHADEO and Dr.CA.Prof.Nishesh Vilekar. "The Evolution of CSR Theory: From Social Responsibility to Stakeholder Capitalism and ESG." International Journal of Advance Research and Innovative Ideas In Education 12, no. 5 (2026): 704-712.
Related Research
EVALUATING INSTITUTIONAL READINESS AND SUPPORT MECHANISMS FOR ONLINE LEARNING INTEGRATION: A STUDY OF EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS IN UDAIPUR CITY
Download PDF
A Conceptual Study on the Impact of AI Tools on Teaching–Learning Outcomes in Higher Education
Download PDF
A STUDY ON IMPACT OF PRICE DISCOUNTS ON CONSUMER BUYING BEHAVIOUR WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO VIVO PHONES
Download PDF
A study on impact of digital literacy on digital payment adoption among rural consumers
Download PDF